skip to main |
skip to sidebar
by Richard L. Weaver II
Myths guide your actions. As important as it is for you to exercise, follow effective nutrition guidelines, and get sufficient sleep, in many cases your attempts to do what will keep you healthy are affected by and, thus, in some cases, contravened by myths. Some of these myths are wired into you, and no matter what scientific evidence is offered, they remain anchored, fixed, and secure.
You may wonder why myths often have such a stranglehold over you and your actions? First, they are what give support to your moral values. Whether it be a belief in faith, authority, human empathy, genuine feelings for others, or rational principles, myths buttress your system of moral values. Second, they give you your personal identity. Identity is an ongoing negotiation within you, between how you choose to narrate particular scenes and the culture within which you live. “I am part of a tightknit family,” “I am part of a larger community,” or “I am part of God’s kingdom,” all can be true; however, each plays a role in the formation of your personal identity. Showing loyalty to your family, town, church, or nation is the result of believing in the “sense of community” myth — and loyalties to friends or community are the result of strong myths that reinforce social bonding.
The third reason myths have such a restrictive hold over you is that they are a way to deal with the mystery of and fears relating to creation and death. For many people it is this related set of myths that provide solace. “It is in the nature of humans to wonder about the unknown and search for answers,” writes Lindsey Murtagh http://www.cs.williams.edu/%7Elindsey/myths/myths.html, in “Common Elements in Creation Myths.” She writes, “At the foundation of nearly every culture is a creation myth that explains how the wonders of the earth came to be. These myths have an immense influence on people's frame of reference. They influence the way people think about the world and their place in relation to their surroundings.”
But, what about the myths that guide your everyday life in the areas of exercise, nutrition, and sleep? How powerful are they? Without them, you are lost. Why? Because they create meaning out of your life and actions. Because they make you believe that you matter, that your daily life has meaning, and that your activities fulfill the myths that guide your actions.
Some of the myths about exercise are precisely those that prevent some from engaging in any kind of exercise program at all. “It’s all in the genes,” suggests, for example, that we don’t even have any control over it. We’re either fit or we’re unfit; it has to do with the cards we’re dealt when we’re born. “No pain, no gain,” is a myth, but certainly some see exercise as a painful way to keep fit. Or, “Once you stop strength training, your muscles will turn to fat.” Then, what’s the point? Leave my fat muscles as they are and avoid the exercise-intervention strategy! Of course, muscles turning to fat or vice versa is a physiological impossibility.
For most reasonable people, the operative philosophy regarding exercise is: “It works.” Why it’s important is discussed on the website longevity meme.org http://www.longevitymeme.org/news/view_news_item.cfm?news_id=3633 At this website, it states that exercise helps avoid damage caused by a sedentary lifestyle, hastens recovery from injuries, and prevents falls. Also, aerobic fitness may prevent a diminished functional capacity, including obesity, diabetes, hypertension, myocardial infarction, stroke, some forms of cancer, and osteoporosis.
Just as there are myths that guide exercising, there are myths, too, that guide the value we give nutrition and diet. The first is that there is a perfect diet that will work for everyone. Just as an example, some people do very well on vegetarian diets while others crash and burn. “One size only fits the people who come in that size,” according to the www.health.com, http://yourtotalhealth.ivillage.com website. Other myths mentioned at www.health.com, http://yourtotalhealth.ivillage.com include, “Cutting carbohydrates helps you lose weight,” “Diet foods help you drop pounds,” “The more you cut calories, the more weight you’ll lose,” “Dairy makes you fat,” or “Brown equals whole-grain.”
At the www.healthcastle.com website, two of the nutrition myths discussed there include sugar and fat. The first myth is that sugar causes diabetes; sugar intake will not cause you to develop the disease. Type 2 diabetes results primarily from three risk factors: 1) a diet high in calories, 2) being overweight, and 3) an inactive lifestyle.
The myth regarding fat is that all fats are bad. Fact is, fats assist nutrient absorption, support nerve transmission, and help maintain cell membrane integrity. Of course, if consumed in excessive amounts they contribute to weight gain, heart disease, and certain types of cancers. But, not all fats are created equal according to www.healthcastle.com. What you have to do is replace bad fats with good fats.
The Medical News Today http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/66363.php website debunks ten common myths regarding nutrition that include eating immediately after a workout to improve recovery, the trouble eating fiber can cause if you have irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), the necessity for consuming extra protein to build muscle mass, that vitamin supplements are necessary for everyone, that all alcohol is bad for you, that eating eggs will raise your cholesterol, that brown grain products are whole grain products, the need to drink eight 8-oz. glasses of water per day, and that eating carbohydrates will make you fat. These are all myths.
In addition to myths governing the way we exercise and eat, there are myths that affect our sleep as well. At the Sleep Disorders http://sleepdisorders.about.com/od/gettingtosleep/a/sleepmyths.htm website two of the twelve myths discussed there are, first, that you can “cheat” on the amount of sleep you get. It can be dangerous to both physical and mental health to do so. Second, it is a myth as well, that you can “catch up” on sleep missed. Once you miss hours of sleep, they are gone forever.
The point of this essay is not necessarily the myths themselves but how myths govern our actions. Because of their importance in our lives, it is wise to be aware of them, check them out, and be flexible in altering those that no longer --- or never did! --- serve a useful purpose.
______________________________________________________________________________
At the SharpBrains, “The Brain Fitness Authority,” website http://www.sharpbrains.com/free-eguide/http://www.sharpbrains.com/free-eguide/ there is a condensed version of a 40-page whitepaper "11 Sharp Brains Debunk 10 Myths on the Science Behind The Nascent Brain Fitness Industry." The whitepaper features 11 in-depth interviews with leading neuroscientists, psychologists and experts in the field of cognition, conducted by Alvaro Fernandez. The 10 myths are listed, and there are brief quotes from the interviews.
“Exploding Exercise Myths” at the infoplease.com website http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0872851.html “Getting Americans off the couch and onto their feet could save an estimated 200,000 lives a year, says the surgeon general. Yet most of us are either sedentary or only minimally active. Confusion may keep many couch potatoes from getting into shape,” are the first sentences at this website. Ten myths are exploded. ______________________________________________________________________________
Contact Richard L. Weaver II
This Thursday’s essay is “Be Aware of the Myths that Guide Your Life.” Myths guide your actions. As important as it is for you to exercise, follow effective nutrition guidelines, and get sufficient sleep, in many cases your attempts to do what will keep you healthy are affected by and, thus, in some cases, contravened by myths. Some of these myths are wired into you, and no matter what scientific evidence is offered, they remain anchored, fixed, and secure.
Share your And Then Some Story about myths. Are you a person who has numerous myths that guide your life? We would love to hear your story? Do you have a friend, a family member, a neighbor, or someone you just know from a distance who has structured a life based on myths? Feel free to use a pseudonym for the person’s real name. What are some of the most-often used myths that you hear? Where do you think the whole experienced of a “myth-based existence” begins? How does it get rooted in our psyche to the extent that myths control and govern our behavior? Let us know what you think.
And Then Some Essay - May 29, 2008
Be Aware of the Myths that Guide Your Lifeby Richard L. Weaver II
Excerpt:
(After discussing why myths have such a stranglehold on you, I then ask the question:) But, what about the myths that guide your everyday life in the areas of exercise, nutrition, and sleep? How powerful are they? Without them, you are lost. Why? Because they create meaning out of your life and actions. Because they make you believe that you matter, that your daily life has meaning, and that your activities fulfill the myths that guide your actions.
-------------------------
Share your 'And Then Some Story'
And Then Some Publishing, LLC wants to hear your story. Whether you share your story through our website, link to your blog, or have a website to share your story we want to hear it.
The only way this feature can work is if you submit your story or link to us. Be the first And Then Some Fan Story to be featured or linked on our blog!
Click here to submit and share your And Then Some story!
And Then Some Works - see you THURSDAY!!
by Richard L. Weaver II
I was reading Christine Comaford-Lynch’s book, Rules for Renegades: How to Make More Money, Rock Your Career, and Revel in Your Individuality (McGraw-Hill, 2007), and I came to her “Ten Steps to Your GSD (Gets Stuff Done)” (pp. 46-50), and I read her sixth suggestion, “Log on to the Law of Attraction” (LOA). In her explanation of this step, Comaford-Lynch writes, “I live by a very cool rule in the universe called the LOA. You’ve heard the saying ‘What you focus on, you become.’ That’s the idea of the LOA.” Comaford-Lynch continues, “When you develop a clear idea of what you want, focus on it, and feel good about it, your mind will consider your wishes to be marching orders.” Her next sentence is the one that causes concern: “The universe will conspire to help to make your dreams come true.”
I will return to her last comment about the universe’s participation in the process in a moment. Before that, however, you need a brief history of the LOA.
The following historical notes are taken directly from Wikipedia and are used here without quotation marks for ease of reading. The LOA concept can be found in Hinduism. The most influential modern book on the subject is As a Man Thinketh by James Allen (1864-1912), which was published in 1902. The title derives from the ancient Jewish Book of Proverbs, chapter 23, verse 7: "As a man thinketh in his heart, so he is." By the mid 20th century, writings on the subject had become common and dozens of authors had addressed the topic under various names, such as positive thinking, "mental science," "pragmatic Christianity," "New Thought," "practical metaphysics," “Science of Mind," and "Religious Science.” In 2006, a film titled The Secret presented the LOA to a new generation; soon after it developed into a book by the same name.
The comments in the remaining portion of this essay are not designed to cast aspersions upon or disparage, in any way, those who believe in the power of positive thinking, use visualization, say positive affirmations to boost their spirits and guide their actions, or have anecdotal proof that the LOA works in their own or others’ lives. According to Wikipedia, once again, “many people who accept the LOA as a guide for right living do so on the basis of their faith in the Universe and The Universe's 'Laws'; thus, to them, the nature of the 'Law' is not one to be settled scientifically, and the word 'Law' carries the same belief-based weight as non-scientific 'Laws' from other religions.” People with these beliefs are unlikely to be swayed by any reasons against the LOA. The purpose of this essay is to show that the LOA is a myth.
Although the definition of the LOA varies greatly, what I am talking about here is the LOA as a theory that “like attracts like” and as applied to the mental life of human beings, suggests that individuals experience in their lives actions and events that correspond to their thoughts, feelings, and words. What this reveals is that believing in the LOA means those individuals have the ability to control the reality of their lives through thought alone.
My first two reasons come from the website of Scott H. Young. The first argument that LOA is a myth is the problem of calling it a law. It is a completely unscientific theory. For something to be called a “law” in science, it must have predictive powers. Evolution is a theory because theories explain; laws predict.
The second reason is that the LOA is impotent. It lacks any basis from which to disprove it. Not only does this render it unscientific but lacking in power as well. For advice to be worthwhile, there must be ways to determine if it is working, and the LOA fails. Often the way it is discussed and presented makes it sound scientific; it is pseudoscience and nothing more.
The third reason is that it is a self-proving concept. That is, if the LOA doesn’t work for you, it is for the same reason as why it works. If positive things happen in your life because you believe in them that proves the LOA. If positive things happen during a time in your life when you are convinced nothing remotely positive could happen or negative things happen when you are 100% convinced they wouldn’t, that would disprove the LOA and cause you to reject it.
The fourth reason is that the LOA is a myth because it simply mimics, and offers little that is new, to the way life works without the LOA. For example, if you went out in traffic looking for red cars, you’ll see many. Your senses are filters, as is your brain, so if you focus on a particular wavelength of stuff, it should be no surprise that you’ll get it. It requires no extraordinary mental jump to the conclusion that life works like that all the time — whatever you focus on, you’ll see more of it, or get more of it. This has nothing to do with the universe conspiring to help you in any way. The universe is simply the aggregate of all existing things.
The fifth reason is that the LOA requires a leap of faith. Comaford-Lynch, for example, puts her faith in an active universe that will conspire to help her. For anyone who believes in the LOA, they will see what they want to see. Many who claim belief in the LOA, or cite personal evidence of its success, are healthy, wealthy, full of joy and love, and the LOA works perfectly. But it works as well for the bitter, depressed, and frustrated who see the world as a horrible place. Their world, too, is the way it is because they think it is that way.
The sixth reason is that the LOA leads people to believe in a wishing well or magic genie. They think by wishing for things hard enough, they will get them. It’s like playing the lottery and doing nothing because when the lottery pays off, you will be successful. It takes more than wishing — and certainly more than waiting for a lottery payout — to make any dream come true. Do you really believe that thinking hard enough about anything will make it come true?
The seventh reason is a question: Do you believe in coincidence, or when random events take place, do you feel they mean something greater?
The eighth reason is that the LOA provides people with the illusion of having control over their lives. Change your attitudes and intentions and any dream you have will come true. If it doesn’t work, it’s your fault because you didn’t genuinely change your attitude or intentions. The LOA is no less a way toward control than faith is a basis for being healed. When you don’t get healed, faith healers will tell you, you simply didn’t have enough faith!
Many people believe in the LOA, especially big name self-help gurus. The LOA is not a proven law of nature, and people do not attract everything in their lives. It is how you think about events and information and the concrete actions you take that give you control of your life. To be healthy and happy you must build your self-esteem, be positive and optimistic, have an open mind, and take action when necessary to make positive changes in your life. There is far better advice in these two sentences than anything the LOA has to offer, and now you have eight reasons to support this view.
______________________________________________________________________________
The definition, history, principles, and criticism of the LOA can be found at Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Attraction It offers the most comprehensive coverage of the topic I have discovered.
Megan Jenifer, at the website Ezine Articles, in an essay, “4 Laws of Attraction Myths,” at http://ezinearticles.com/?4-Law-of-Attraction-Myths&id=914954 discusses 1) the LOA is not a law, 2) the LOA is all about choices, 3) feelings are just feelings; they don’t matter, and 4) the LOA only works if you take action.
______________________________________________________________________________
Contact Richard L. Weaver II
“‘The Secret’ reveals the most powerful law in the universe. The knowledge of this law has run like a golden thread through the lives and the teachings of all the prophets, seers, sages and saviors in the world's history, and through the lives of all truly great men and women. All that they have ever accomplished or attained has been done in full accordance with this most powerful law.’” This is a quote from the home page of “The Secret,” and if you believe it, then you need to read this Thursday’s essay entitled, “Reasons why the Law of Attraction (LOA) is a myth.” There is no doubt that “knowledge of this law has run...through the lives and the teachings of all prophets, seers, sages and saviors,” but that neither makes it true nor right. Read the essay; decide for yourself.
Share your And Then Some Story about the myths of our society and world. Have you ever been “sucked in” by old wives tales, superstitions, and urban legends? Has your belief in any of these caused you to behave (or not behave) in some specific fashion? How were you affected? What caused you to realize the falsity of the belief, and when did it happen? In what ways can we move more quickly (as a society) to put an end to such bunk before it has a chance to take hold and have impact?
And Then Some Essay - April 17, 2008
Reasons why the Law of Attraction (LOA) is a mythby Richard L. Weaver II
Excerpt:
Although the definition of the LOA (Law of Attraction) varies greatly, what I am talking about here is the LOA as a theory that “like attracts like” and as applied to the mental life of human beings, suggests that individuals experience in their lives actions and events that correspond to their thoughts, feelings, and words. What this reveals is that believing in the LOA means those individuals have the ability to control the reality of their lives through thought alone.
-------------------------
Share your 'And Then Some Story'
And Then Some Publishing wants to hear your story. An important part of the And Then Some philosophy revolves around you and how you interpret the concepts and ideas. Saturday Essays on our blog and our book of essays are just guidelines to and our impressions of the And Then Some philosophy; they are not hard and fast rules or concepts embedded in cement. Every individual interprets life differently just as everyone interprets And Then Some just a little differently. In the end, everyone has the same goal, however...And Then Some --- Give more, Get more, Want more from life!
We are compiling your stories for a special And Then Some book built from your experiences. Also, some stories will be chosen to be posted on our blog. The only way this feature can work is if you submit your story on how And Then Some works in your life. We're starting from ground zero and we need your stories! Please... Submit and share your story... please. Be the first And Then Some Fan Story to be featured on our blog!
Click here to submit and share your And Then Some story!
And Then Some Works - see you THURSDAY!!