Showing posts with label ethos. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ethos. Show all posts

Thursday, October 8, 2009

Credibility has a direct influence on public-speaking effectiveness

by Richard L. Weaver II

When I taught the basic speech communication course, one of the cautions I offered students at the outset of the term, was to be careful about their credibility—their character in the eyes of others. Because their instructor, as well as their peers, would, at least in part, be determining their grade in the course, if they did things early-on in the course that would have a negative impact on their credibility, it would directly affect what occurred later.

You can’t make careless comments, come late to class, reveal characteristics that could make others question their trust in you, or show any degree of disrespect for the instructor or other class members, if you expect them to trust you, respect you, and value you later in the course.

The public-speaking portion of the course occurred during the final portion of the term, and speeches were evaluated by the instructor with direct input from all class members. Credibility has a direct influence on public-speaking effectiveness, just as it does on most aspects of our lives.

Carefully crafted credibility causes others to remain enthralled by your depth, complexity, and completeness. It not only captures attention but, often, causes others to want to emulate you.

Overall, it is important for you to look, sound, and act the part of a credible person. When your message and your credibility are not congruent (out of synchronization with each other), an unfavorable decision may be made.

The problem with credibility is first, that so many elements are involved in its composition. The second problem is that, often, it takes a long time to establish credibility, but it can disappear completely in the blink of an eye.

Why is it, for example, as Malcolm Gladwell, in his book, Blink (Little, Brown, 2005) explains, that art experts are able to detect forgeries nearly the second they look at an object? —Before they can conclusively even explain why they know it is a forgery, they can make a decision.

And the same is true for most people when they size-up others. Even though they may not be able to explain exactly why they feel as they do, they know whether or not they trust them. The difficulty is trying to isolate all the variables that make up credibility. Not only may some factors be personal, but the way factors interact also poses a problem.

One factor that may engender trust is the simple fact that someone took an interest in you, treated you as a personality, or made you feel important. It could be that they turned the spotlight on you—even if it was ever so briefly or quickly. It could be, too, that they simply let you know they were impressed by you.

When others let you know they are impressed by you, the most common reaction is to judge them the smartest, most knowledgeable and personable individuals in the world.

There are two levels of credibility. People often make judgments of speakers prior to the speech. Such judgments follow the cliche, “your reputation precedes you,” and they are based upon everything you know or have heard about speakers before you see and hear them in person. This is the level referred to in the opening paragraph of this essay when students are cautioned that what they do in class prior to the speech portion of the course, can hurt them.

All speakers can create a resume, establish credentials, build a reputation, or develop expertise, and all of these are important as speakers move toward delivering a speech. In general, however, they are completed before the speech occasion itself, and introducers of speakers make a point of highlighting many of those accomplishments.

But, the question here is, what can speakers do to build their credibility within the speech itself. It is the second level of credibility.

If you are a public speaker, and if your goal is to persuade others, there are a number of well-known, specific factors over which you have direct control. These factors can be grouped under the categories of competence, trustworthiness, and dynamism.

Competence is related to your knowledge base — how much you know. Are you trained, qualified, informed, and authoritative? The way to develop competence within a speech is to quote people who are acknowledged experts on your topic. Refer to your research effort, use the special vocabulary of experts, without being a verbal show off, and mention your personal involvement with your topic.

There are two other ways that can reveal competence, too, that are often overlooked. First, list the important facts or issues pertinent to your topic, even though you may later ignore all but a few of the issues during the body of your speech. People perceive lists as revealing knowledge or analytic skills.

Second, and this may be one of the most important ways people have to reveal competence, be organized. The organizational pattern you follow as you approach your topic is unimportant; the clarity of your organization reveals sound speech analysis.

Trustworthiness relates to the relationship you have with your audience in any particular speech context. Do listeners think you are kind, safe, friendly, and pleasant? To build trust, self-disclose (for example, what are your private reasons for being interested in your topic?), compliment your audience, ask for trust, demonstrate an awareness of alternative positions, claim your prior commitment (for example, remind your audience of your prior actions), claim common ground with your audience (for example, demonstrate that your basic orientation is compatible with theirs), and look your listeners in the eye as you communicate with them.

Dynamism is what is known as an activity dimension because it relates to how aggressive, bold, and forceful you are. To support dynamism within your speech, demonstrate active and emotional commitment to your topic. Be a fluent and purposeful speaker. And, by all means, exhibit an animated delivery style that verifies and underscores your concern, involvement, and interest.

As noted, credibility has a direct influence on public-speaking effectiveness, just as it does on most aspects of our lives. Not only must we be vigilant in constructing our credibility, but we must be even more vigilant and cautious in preserving it as well.
-----

Christine W. Zust, at the website EmergingLeader.com, has an essay entitled, “Communicating with credibility,” in which she discusses eight ways for developing (or maintaining) credibility: 1) align your verbal and nonverbal language, 2) lead by listening, 3) make realistic promises and keep them, 4) speak from the heart, 5) be yourself, 6) be an expert, 7) be honest, and 8) be proactive.


At the Thomas Group Ltd. website, there is a wonderful essay by Paul Thomas under his byline, “Thomas Tips,” entitled, “Establishing personal credibility,” which is specifically designed for those who are in, going in, or planning for a future in business. This is one of those “must read” essays full of practical, applicable, and useful suggestions.


You can read more about credibility in my book, Public Speaking Rules: All You Need for a Great Speech. Chapter 7, "Develop Your Credibility," (pages 75-92) discusses how you develop it through quality communication, before a speech, during a speech, and through interaction with your listeners. This book covers the nuts-and-bolts rules necessary for giving a great speech, and the book is both easy to read and easy to use.
-----


Copyright October, 2009 - And Then Some Publishing L.L.C.


Tuesday, October 6, 2009

And Then Some News

Thursday’s essay is called, “Credibility has a direct influence on public-speaking effectiveness.” This essay takes me back to my lectures in the basic speech-communication course I directed for many years. Why? Because, as you will read in the essay, I had to remind students that what they did (their behavior) in the first parts of the course would have a direct influence on the assessments they would receive later in the course. In this essay I discuss several important ways for developing it.

Share your link. Have you written anything about credibility? Are you a person who has had to develop his or her own credibility? What situations have you encountered in which credibility was an important factor? Can you share some insights about how to develop it, how important it is, or what happens when it is lost? How important has credibility been in your life? Why does it matter? What would you like to tell people about credibility? Share your link with us. We’ll post it and move traffic in your direction. And, a big “thank you,” in advance, from AndThenSomeWorks.com, for sharing your link.


Thursday's And Then Some Essay preview:
Credibility has a direct effect on public-speaking effectiveness
by Richard L. Weaver II

Excerpt:


Trustworthiness relates to the relationship you have with your audience in any particular speech context. Do listeners think you are kind, safe, friendly, and pleasant? To build trust, self-disclose (for example, what are your private reasons for being interested in your topic?), compliment your audience, ask for trust, demonstrate an awareness of alternative positions, claim your prior commitment (for example, remind your audience of your prior actions), claim common ground with your audience (for example, demonstrate that your basic orientation is compatible with theirs), and look your listeners in the eye as you communicate with them.


And Then Some Works - see you Thursday!!

Saturday, January 19, 2008

Martin Luther King’s ‘I Have a Dream’ speech — The greatest and most notable speech in history

by Richard L. Weaver II

Martin Luther King’s “I Have A Dream” speech, delivered August 28, 1963, was a defining moment of the American Civil Rights Movement. Given from the steps of the Lincoln Memorial to over two-hundred thousand civil rights supporters, the speech lasted only sixteen minutes. According to U.S. Congressman, John Lewis, who also spoke that day as the President of the Student Non-Violent Coordinating Committee, “"Dr. King had the power, the ability and the capacity to transform those steps on the Lincoln Memorial into a modern day pulpit. By speaking the way he did, he educated, he inspired, he informed not just the people there, but people throughout America and unborn generations.”

There was more taking place when King gave his speech than would at first be apparent. To the untrained eye, his speech was moving, encouraging, even galvanizing. To the trained eye, however, it was truly a model speech and, indeed, one of the greatest and most notable speeches in history. It has been ranked the top American speech of the 20th century by a 1999 poll of scholars of public address.

The obvious question is, “Why is it a model speech?”

For 22 years I delivered a lecture entitled, “Persuasion: The Unity of Logos, Pathos, and Ethos,” to close to 80,000 undergraduates. In this lecture I examined the speech. This essay is a condensation of that lecture, and I have divided it into the three parts: logos, pathos, and ethos.

Logos means logic, and as a persuasive strategy, speakers use a clearly stated main purpose, a well-defined thought pattern, and effective major arguments supported by evidence. In his “I Have a Dream” speech, King used mostly his own personal experience and observations to support his major arguments. His purpose statement is, “Now is the time to make justice a reality for all of God’s children.”

Perhaps the most important aspect of King’s logic was how he organized his ideas. He followed Monroe’s motivated sequence. It is a pattern that works because it follows the normal process of human reasoning. I told students that if I had to pick out one piece of information that I considered most important — from all of my 15 lectures — it would be this five-step sequence. If you ever have to give a problem-solving persuasive speech, I highly recommend it. It is so effective and powerful, most advertisements you see on television follow it precisely.

The five steps of the Monroe motivated sequence are attention, need, satisfaction, visualization and action.
In the attention step speakers call attention to the situation. King, speaking from the steps of the Lincoln Memorial, calls attention to Lincoln’s signing of the Emancipation Proclamation, the situation of the Negro today (“One hundred years later, the Negro still is not free.”), and the fact that the words of the Constitution and Declaration of Independence granting all people the unalienable rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness have not been fulfilled.

For the need step, speakers describe the difficulty, trouble, distress, crisis, emergency, or urgency. King says, “Instead of honoring this sacred obligation [what the Constitution and Declaration of Independence promise], America has given the Negro people a bad check, a check that has come back marked ‘insufficient funds.’” And why have they come to Washington, D.C.? — to “remind America of the fierce urgency of now.”

In the satisfaction step, speakers tell listeners how to satisfy the need they establish. King says, “We must make the pledge that we shall always march ahead.” To march ahead, he said, “We can never be satisfied.” Then he tells listeners to go back home knowing their situation can and will be changed.

For visualization, speakers offer listeners a vision of what life can be once their solution (offered in the satisfaction step) is adopted. This is where King offers listeners his dream: “I have a dream” offered along with five different descriptions of what life can and will be like in Georgia, Mississippi, Alabama, in communities, and around the world.

The final stage is the action step when speakers offer listeners a specific course of action to follow. King’s action step occurs when he asks his audience to “Let freedom ring,” and he uses the phrase at the end of the speech focusing on eight states symbolizing the whole nation.

Pathos means emotion, and King depends on his use of language to draw emotion from his listeners. Figures of speech predominate. Antithesis, or the setting of one clause or other member of a sentence against another to which it is opposed, is heavily used. “It came as a joyous daybreak to end their long night of captivity,” is the first of many examples of antithesis used in the speech.

King also uses many other figures of speech. Simile is the comparison of two unlike things, connected with the words “like” or “as” such as “justice rolls down like waters and righteousness like a mighty stream.” Metaphor is a compressed simile (the “like” or “as” is eliminated) and they are abundant: “manacles of segregation,” “symphony of brotherhood.” Allusions, or references to literary, historical, and biblical events, occur often. “Five score years ago” refers to the Gettysburg Address, and there are biblical allusions to Psalm 30:5, Amos 5:24, and Isaiah 40:4. In addition, King uses personification, hyperbole, contrast, colloquialisms, repetition, refrain (anaphora), and parallelism.

Ethos means the character of the speaker in the eyes of the audience. King was born into a well-educated, successful family, graduated from Morehouse College, and, as the outstanding member of his senior class, from Crozer Theological Seminary. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy in 1955, and served as minister of the Dexter Avenue Baptist Church from 1955 to 1968. His Nobel Peace Prize was received one year after this speech was given.

The “I Have a Dream” speech served as a precursor to the passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965. King was Time’s “Man of the Year” for 1963. As a speech, it was the greatest and most notable in history and served as a model for the way it demonstrated the unity of logos, pathos, and ethos.

--------------------------------

For pictures, a YouTube audio and video of the speech, and for a text of the “I Have a Dream” speech, see: www.americanrhetoric.com/speeches/mlkihaveadream.htm

For an online biography of Martin Luther King Jr., see: nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/peace/laureates/1964/king-bio.html

--------------------------------




Contact Richard L. Weaver II

-----------------------------------------

And Then Some: Essays to Entertain, Motivate, & Inspire - Book 1

Signed copy of Book 1 for $16.47 while supplies last!