Showing posts with label girls. Show all posts
Showing posts with label girls. Show all posts

Thursday, August 21, 2008

Dealing With Mediocre Teachers

by Richard L. Weaver II

It would be nice to believe all teachers are hard working, competent, and dedicated. Most educators fit that description, but as in every profession, there is mediocrity as well.

Having mediocre teachers “in the system” may be symptomatic of our culture. That is, what was once considered substandard is now considered acceptable. What was once merely average is now above average or excellent. When this social atmosphere prevails, true excellence is feared and must be challenged. If this is the same culture by which criteria are established for measuring competence, it is not difficult to see how it is partly to blame for mediocrity being protected — maybe even being undetectable.

Mediocrity can result from institutionalized incentive programs, too. Teachers have lifetime job security, and their pay is based on salary schedules that have nothing to do with talent, effort, success, or even on how much students learn. Great teachers are rewarded only if they leave teaching for other careers whereas mediocre teachers stick around knowing their weak performance is tolerated.

Another possible explanation for mediocrity is the education system itself. It teaches to the middle and sets goals no higher than average. And, if you were to watch mediocre teachers, the message is often in the nonverbal cues they convey — the way they enter the room, where they stand, how they engage the pupils, the use of insecure gestures, poor classroom positioning, and even the failure to smile. Seldom is it in how much knowledge they have.

Because the clues are, generally, nonverbal, students can judge the quality of a teacher within ten seconds of seeing them, and their judgments tend to be consistently correct.

The question is, to what extent is the mediocrity of teachers harmful to the education of students? One could argue that average is all right since it is so much better than substandard. What the system needs to do is rid itself of the lousy teachers, offer modest retention bonuses to the mediocre, and compensate excellence with pay raises, sabbaticals, free education, available and well-marked parking spaces, quality students, and other perks.

One of the problems may be with expectations. Should parents expect our educational system to turn every child into a genius? Should education be responsible for unleashing each child’s true potential? I don’t think it’s being cynical to mention that most students are average (half above and half below), and many — its true — are likely to grow up to be truck drivers and WalMart clerks. They will play video games, watch TV six hours a day, and surf the Internet— once their true potential has been unleashed, of course.

Our society has become obsessed with the illusion that everyone is special. Every one has some talent, genius, or brilliance that has been unfairly suppressed, and it is the responsibility of education, and teachers as the stewards of that precious commodity, to coax, prod, and goad it out of them. We could become a nation of gods, they believe, if only we had better teachers!

One point that is missed in all of this is that our teachers — mediocre or not — are far better than most students could ever utilize. Even mediocre teachers can offer more knowledge of higher quality than 90 percent of their students can absorb. Giving students a mediocre education is far better than teaching them answers to standardized tests. It was Robert Hutchins who said, “It must be remembered that the purpose of education is not to fill the minds of students with facts...it is to teach them to think, if that is possible, and always to think for themselves.”

The goal of education must always be recruiting quality teachers who can get students to think. The problem is simply that judging whether or not future teachers have this ability is like judging — before a marriage — whether or not a future partner will be satisfactory.

There must be more in-school training, more observation, more focus on the micro-skills of teaching. We can better utilize technology to coach and analyze what goes on within and beyond classrooms. With digital technology we can record then freeze-frame and analyze body language — how potential teachers use gestures, intonation, facial expressions, and eye contact — verbal mannerisms, as well as the proxemics of both trainee and established teachers. Why not have experienced teachers who are considered “master teachers” use microphones to coach and give trainees who are equipped with earpieces, instant advice and feedback just as it occurs in sports? Why wait until the end of lessons for retrospective, stale advice?

There need to be far more observations of trainees by a wide variety of teachers, and not just those who teach the same subject. Why not create a cradle-to-grave approach to staff development that expects career progression from all staff members beginning from their earliest years? Those who dare to teach must never cease to learn. Potential teachers must visit a variety of teachers to see how lessons are taught, knowledge conveyed, classroom interaction occurs, and students are challenged.

Performance management must focus on the skills teachers need to make them better teachers rather than on the hoops they need to jump through to get more pay or higher rank. Also, cradle-to-grave approaches to staff development should not just recognize the essential skills and experiences of older staff but use them — even retired “master teachers” — to mentor and tutor rookies.

William Arthur Ward, the educator, author, poet, pastor, and motivational speaker, said, “The mediocre teacher tells. The good teacher explains. The superior teacher demonstrates. The great teacher inspires.” I contend that with cradle-to-crave approaches to staff development, all of these can be contained in a single teacher — not four separate individuals. There are times for telling just as there are times for explaining, demonstrating, and inspiring. We need to recruit quality teachers, true, but we need to train them, too, to strive for quality because to teach is to touch lives forever.




A great article about mediocre teachers:
http://64.233.167.104/search?q=cache:cuoO8CmFcvwJ:www.nctq.org/nctq/research/1135269588003.pdf+mediocre+teachers&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=1&gl=us

“Outstanding Teachers Share Tips for Success,” is an essay written for The Honolulu Advertiser, and it can be found at: http://the.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/2004/Nov/18/ln/ln09p.html The tips here are from Katherine Nakamura and Clyde Hashimoto, and the article is written by Treena Shapiro, the Advertiser’s writer on education. These are great tips and useful for every teacher.







Contact Richard L. Weaver II

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

And Then Some News

And Then Some Works NewsThursday’s essay, “Dealing With Mediocre Teachers,” is the second of a number of essays that relate to education. That I write essays on education, as I said last week, is easily understood since I spent close to 48 years involved in public education as either a student or teacher.

Share your And Then Some Story about teachers you have had. Have you had mediocre teachers? Outstanding teachers? Can you tell us what’s the difference? What are the characteristics of mediocre teachers? Of outstanding teachers? Can you share your tips, stories, or suggestions regarding outstanding teaching? In what ways can outstanding teachers contribute to one’s life? We would love to hear your story. Do you have a friend, a family member, a neighbor, or someone you just know from a distance who has been turned on or turned off as a result of a teacher or teachers? Can you tell his or her story? Feel free to use a pseudonym for the person’s real name.


Thursday's And Then Some Essay preview
Dealing With Mediocre Teachers
by Richard L. Weaver II

Excerpt:

Having mediocre teachers “in the system” may be symptomatic of our culture. That is, what was once considered substandard is now considered acceptable. What was once merely average is now above average or excellent. When this social atmosphere prevails, true excellence is feared and must be challenged. If this is the same culture by which criteria are established for measuring competence, it is not difficult to see how it is partly to blame for mediocrity being protected — maybe even being undetectable.
-------------------------

Share your And Then Some storyShare your 'And Then Some Story'

And Then Some Publishing, LLC wants to hear your story. Whether you share your story through our website, link to your blog, or have a website to share your story we want to hear it.

The only way this feature can work is if you submit your story or link to us.
Be the first And Then Some Fan Story to be featured or linked on our blog!

Click here to submit and share your And Then Some story!

And Then Some Works - see you THURSDAY!!

Thursday, August 14, 2008

What is the Importance of Public Education?

by Richard L. Weaver II

We hear the results in a wide variety of places. At a local nursery, the owner explained why most all of his helpers were women by using his thumbs to indicate that men’s problems could all be traced to a preoccupation with handheld video games. “All they want to do is play,” he said. Another local employer of part-time helpers explained that it is impossible to find qualified males saying, “There are few men who are even interested, and those few lack the qualifications. They don’t know much, and they don’t care.”

In a report by the Independent Women’s Forum of Washington, D.C., entitled, “Taking the Boy Crisis in Education Seriously,” (April 2007), Krista Kafer makes the case that, “Boys, not girls, are being left behind by our nation’s schools.” She backs up this conclusion in an astounding paragraph of findings:

Girls surpass boys in reading, writing, civics and the arts. Girls get better grades and more honors; they have higher aspirations, are more engaged in school and are more likely to graduate from high school and college. Boys, on the other hand, are more likely to be suspended or expelled, need special education, smoke, drink, and do drugs, repeat a grade, commit suicide, become incarcerated, leave school without attaining literacy, drop out of school or be unemployed. Marginal advantages in math and science for boys pale compared to the sheer advantage girls enjoy throughout school.

Kafer makes it clear that this is no “manufactured crisis” or a “backlash against the women’s movement” as some feminist authors have suggested.

A survey of high-school seniors found that girls are more likely to participate in music and performing arts activities, academic clubs, student council or government, and join the newspaper and yearbook. Also, they are more likely to participate in community affairs, or volunteer once or twice a month. The only extracurricular activity boys are likely to take part in is athletics.

A survey of high-school sophomores found that girls are more likely to perform community service, take music, art, and language classes, read at least three hours a week of non-school reading, and talk on the phone. Boys work on hobbies, drive or ride around, visit with friends, play sports, watch television, and play video games. Of those who said they watched 6 or more hours of television, 22 percent were boys and 15 percent were girls.

The public education system must respond with innovative strategies and environments that help boys and girls, because the consequences of these conditions are serious. The U.S. Department of Labor estimates that 60% of the new jobs being created in our economy today will require technological literacy, yet only 22% of the young people entering the job market now actually possess those skills. By 2010, all jobs will require some form of technological literacy, and 80% of those jobs haven’t even been created yet. Students must be prepared for a world that even we ourselves cannot completely anticipate. If students do not know how to learn, and if they do not have a desire to learn, adaptation to and flexibility within a new, uncertain environment tomorrow is unlikely.

What both educators and students must understand is that scientific knowledge is doubling every few years. As a result of breathtaking changes—the sudden growth of information technologies, medical breakthroughs, and advances in genetic engineering, for example—most major societal institutions are in a state of change. Yet schools remain much the same institutions as our grandparents attended. Faced with this flood of change—in large measure driven by science and technology—we are, as a society, failing miserably to produce an informed and scientifically literate populace.

We are in dire need of a serious discussion in this country about the importance of public
education, what our children actually need to be taught, and the extent to which quality instruction currently exists. Schools need to increase everyday standards for classroom attendance, behavior, homework completion, and academic participation and cooperation. And consequences for not meeting these standards also need to be increased and enforced.

Failing to hold students accountable for inappropriate behavior and unproductive
academic performance is a recipe for lowering standards to the point where individuals no longer believe that the rules apply to them. Often, students spend more time complaining about educational requirements they are expected to follow instead of attending classes and figuring out and using constructive strategies for passing.

Once we focus more on instilling academic values in our students instead of worrying
about bruising their egos, damaging their self-esteem, or stifling their voice, our schools will finally begin to recover the ground lost to the specter of low expectations. Doing so will do more to indicate increased standards than any exit exam ever could.

Good schools that help boys and girls reach their potential exist in both the public and private sector. The existence of some of these schools, however, is insufficient. Public education must embrace innovation and encourage the replication of strategies—wherever they can be found—that will help boys and girls reach their potential. If this means allowing families to choose schools, single-sex schools or classrooms, new charter-school laws, unique scholarship programs, or instituting new math and science requirements, the development of innovative strategies must be the goal if we are not just to give every boy and girl the chance to succeed, but if we are to be successful in providing society with an informed and scientifically literate populace. Kafer writes that, “Successful single-sex classrooms and single-sex schools can have a positive effect on student achievement for boys and girls. Such environments can break down stereotypes and help girls attain high achievement in math and science and boys attain high achievement in reading and writing.”

Public education is important, but we need to approach it in such a way that we both recognize and emphasize its importance, but, most importantly, strengthen and improve it.




This Wikepedia essay on public education is outstanding. To read the essay, go to the web site: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_education Here, you will not just find the reasons for, funding and history of public education, also you will find an explanation of its development in Israel and Scotland as a foundation for the system eventually established in the United States.

At http://www.engines4ed.org/hyperbook/nodes/NODE-40-pg.html the essay is entitled, “Why Schools Fail Our Children,” and the essay is strong, but more important are the links to further brief essays on the role of the teacher, what does the future hold, why children lack motivation, and at least a dozen other topics.







Contact Richard L. Weaver II

Tuesday, August 12, 2008

And Then Some News

Thursday’s essay, “The Importance of Public Education,” is the first of a number of essays that relate to education. That I write essays on education is easily understood since I spent close to 48 years involved in public education as either a student or teacher.

Share your And Then Some Story about public education. Have you been involved in public education? As a student or teacher? What was or is your experience? Can you share your tips, stories, or suggestions regarding public education? How successful have you been as a student or teacher? In what ways has public education contributed positively or negatively to your life? We would love to hear your story. Do you have a friend, a family member, a neighbor, or someone you just know from a distance who has been involved in public education? Can you tell his or her story? Feel free to use a pseudonym for the person’s real name.


Thursday's And Then Some Essay preview
What is the Importance of Public Education?
by Richard L. Weaver II

Excerpt:

The public education system must respond with innovative strategies and environments that help boys and girls, because the consequences of these conditions are serious. The U.S. Department of Labor estimates that 60% of the new jobs being created in our economy today will require technological literacy, yet only 22% of the young people entering the job market now actually possess those skills. By 2010, all jobs will require some form of technological literacy, and 80% of those jobs haven’t even been created yet. Students must be prepared for a world that even we ourselves cannot completely anticipate. If students do not know how to learn, and if they do not have a desire to learn, adaptation to and flexibility within a new, uncertain environment tomorrow is unlikely.
-------------------------

Share your 'And Then Some Story'

And Then Some Publishing, LLC wants to hear your story. Whether you share your story through our website, link to your blog, or have a website to share your story we want to hear it.

The only way this feature can work is if you submit your story or link to us.
Be the first And Then Some Fan Story to be featured or linked on our blog!

Click here to submit and share your And Then Some story!

And Then Some Works - see you THURSDAY!!

Thursday, May 1, 2008

Gender Differences Need to be Acknowledged, Accepted, and Exploited

by Richard L. Weaver II

For all of my growing years everyone thought that male and female differences occurred because parents raised girls and boys in different ways. But the truth is the other way around. Parents raise girls and boys differently because girls and boys are so different from birth. The differences can be noticed in the way girls and boys play, learn, fight, process emotions, and see the world. All these differences come about because their brains are wired differently.

Much of this essay has been drawn from a book entitled Why Gender Matters: What Parents and Teachers Need to Know About the Emerging Science of Sex Differences (Broadway Books, 2005) by Leonard Sax, M.D., PhD. Sax challenges many of the basic assumptions regarding gender differences by interspersing hard data and numerous case studies. This is an outstanding work of scholarship, and in this essay I avoid using quotation marks to indicate my use of this source because of the distraction quotation marks create.

Differences between males and females go on and on. In friendships, for example, girls’ friendships can be characterized as face-to-face — two or three girls talking with one another — whereas boys’ friendships are shoulder-to-shoulder — a group of boys looking out at some common interest (like a video game or a sporting event). Girls confide in each other about their most personal doubts and difficulties; most boys don’t want to hear about each other’s innermost secrets. Close friendships between girls are usually intimate and personal. Friendships between boys are usually built around shared activities.

There are many other differences, too. For example, one occurs in how females and males give directions. Girls are more likely to use visible landmarks whereas boys are more likely to use compass directions: north, south, east, and west. In another example, girls and boys turn to drugs for different reasons. Girls use drugs to lose weight, relieve stress, to calm down, and because their friends are doing it. Most boys who abuse drugs are looking for a thrill. They want the excitement of doing something dangerous. Also, boys are more likely to buy illegal drugs from strangers (risk-taking behavior), while girls buy most of their drugs from people they know. Yet another difference is how girls and boys respond to types of discipline. Boys respond well to strict and authoritarian discipline, which might include occasional spanking. For girls, a warm and fuzzy approach is the one that best promotes social skills; strict discipline may even have a slight negative effect on girls’ social development.

There are many other differences as well, however, as parents we would all like our children to grow up to be courageous and self-confident — attributes traditionally considered masculine. But we also want them to be nurturing, thoughtful, and good listeners — attributes traditionally seen as feminine. We want our children to grow into adults who are comfortable expressing both feminine and masculine attributes — whatever is appropriate for the situation.

The best way to raise androgynous children is to first let them be who they are. The appropriate quotation is, “You can’t be at home everywhere until you are at home somewhere.” Once your children are sure of who they are, they will be more confident, more able to explore gender-atypical ways of learning and listening.

But why does gender matter? A group of distinguished scholars at Dartmouth Medical School determined that our society’s neglect of gender differences has caused great harm. It deeply influences their well-being, they said.

Gender may be more fundamental to learning than age. Noted Georgetown University professor Deborah Tannen compared how girls and boys of different ages use language. In her book, You Just Don’t Understand (HaarperCollins, 2001), she said she “was overwhelmed by the differences that separated the females and males at each age, and the striking similarities that linked the females, on one hand, and the males, on the other, across the vast expanse of age. In many ways,” she writes, “the second-grade girls were more like the twenty-five-year-old women than like the second-grade boys.” Why is this important? Because it affects children’s ability to listen, willingness to affiliate with adults, and their emotional development.

Girls and boys assess risk differently, and they differ in their likelihood of engaging in risky behaviors. In play behavior, for example, boys are more likely to put their fingers into an electrical socket, try to stand on a basketball, or jump off a chair. Even when told to stop doing something risky, boys are less likely to comply. Studies in the United States and around the world universally find that boys are more likely to engage in physically risky activities. Why is this important? Because boys are more likely to be seriously injured or killed in accidents such as drowning, misuse of firearms, or head injury related to riding a bicycle, or playing in extreme sports. For boys, doing something dangerous or stupid increases when in a group of boys.

According to a study by the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA), the gender gap in reading — favoring girls at the expense of boys — has grown from a small gap to a yawning chasm. “What was formerly a moderate difference is fast becoming a decided marker of gender identity. “Girls read; boys don’t,” the study reports. In addition, the NEA noted that boys are disengaging from school. More boys are dropping out, and a smaller proportion are going on to college. Those men who attend college are less likely to earn a diploma, and those who do earn a diploma are less likely to go on to graduate school. There are, thus, less American men earning PhDs in math and science, and because American women have not stepped in to fill the breach, the gap is being filled by foreign students. One writer has suggested that the decline in numbers of Americans studying advanced math and science may adversely affect national security.

Because gender runs near to the core of human identity and social meaning, the neglect of gender differences hinders our children in the guidance they receive about what it means to be an adult woman or man. Sax goes so far as to say that future generations will look back on this one and claim that “a fundamental cause for the unraveling of our social fabric was the neglect of gender in the raising of our children (p. 251).”

“Differences between girls and boys are natural. Those differences should be acknowledged, accepted, and exploited” (p. 63). The fact is that girls and boys differ in learning, risk assessment, the pursuit of education, in how they transition from boys and girls into men and women, and in many other ways. Parents and teachers need to adopt strategies that will get the best out of every child.
______________________________________________________________________________

“Contrary to the wishful thinking of feminists, bisexuals, and transsexuals, there are profound differences between males and females--and those differences are programmed within the DNA from the moment of conception. The brains of females and males are clearly "sexed," and testosterone and estrogen are the juices that augment maleness and femaleness.” These are the concluding comments from this well-written essay, “Gender Differences Are Real,” by Frank York at the Narth website http://www.narth.com/docs/york.html.

From ScienceDaily http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/03/080303120346.htm the essay, “Boys' And Girls' Brains Are Different: Gender Differences In Language Appear Biological,” discusses the biological basis that may explain why the gender differences exist.
______________________________________________________________________________





Contact Richard L. Weaver II